HEARTS OF STONE AND DEAF EARS
Hurricane Katrina made landfall Monday last week, with the levees starting to give way shortly thereafter. The rest, as they say, history.
There have undoubtedly been a truly tragic number of deaths, some unavoidable, and some most likely, with the crystal clarity of hindsight, avoidable.
The political fall-out from all this is truly going to fill the history books, with folks at every level (federal, state, and local) that will eventually have to take some of the blame, and/or will have blame shoved upon them by all parties concerned.
And many that are truly responsible for some of the mis-steps shall escape unscathed as occurs time and time again in every human disaster, whether at the hands of nature or man.
But this post is not about exploring all these very weighty issues in depth. They will play out in front of our eyes over the coming months, mostly in Washington, along with a pretty charged set of hearings for two Supreme Court vacancies.
As an aside, congress-folks from both sides of the political aisle are going to be like pigs in nature's byproducts this fall in terms of opportunities for ample media coverage.
It's going to make or break many a political career, and it'll rival anything else on TV, sitcom, drama, miniseries or reality.
No, this post is about trying to answer the one question that was implicitly raised by the man most charged with making an immediate difference in the aftermath of Katrina. A person who has already had a fair bit of coverage in terms of his qualifications for the job, insinuations of cronyism, and his ability to put his foot in his mouth on a consistent basis.
I'm talking about of course the man of the hour, the man whose head seems to be most desired for by the media at large, the one, the only, Michael Brown, current director of FEMA. (By the way, note that his official biography on the FEMA web-site makes no mention at all of his true occupation for several years prior to the job, as a director of the International Arabian Horse Association...talk about creative resume writing).
In an interview as late as last Thursday on CNN, Mr. Brown said the following in response to an observation that the death toll from this catastrophe would likely be in the thousands:
"Unfortunately, that's going to be attributable a lot to people who did not heed the advance warnings," Brown told CNN.
"I
don't make judgments about why people chose not to leave but, you know,
there was a mandatory evacuation of New Orleans," he said.
"And
to find people still there is just heart-wrenching to me because, you
know, the mayor did everything he could to get them out of there.
"So,
we've got to figure out some way to convince people that whenever
warnings go out it's for their own good," Brown said. "Now, I don't
want to second guess why they did that. My job now is to get relief to
them."
Those warm and comforting words are spoken like a true bureaucrat, by a person not even qualified to BE a bureaucrat, according to many media accounts.
The words also bring to mind the image of a paramedic, who while pulling the wounded driver from a crashed, burning car, mutters under his breath, "Took that last curve a mite too fast now, did we?"
I had to re-read them a couple of times to make sure I didn't miss anything. After all FEMA is the agency charged most with immediate, compassionate rescue and care of American citizens in the aftermath of disasters, or so I believe.
Now, I don't want to single out Mr. Brown for "foot-in-mouth" disease, and/or insensitive, inappropriate comments...he has some company, as this list from obeythetoaster.com shows, including another one from Mr. Brown himself.
Well, someone send Mr. Brown a copy of an excellent start to a response to his implied question. The Washington Post on Sunday ran an article that provided part of the answer in its title: "Living paycheck to paycheck made leaving impossible". Some notable excerpts, provided in vivid vignettes:
"To those who wonder why so many stayed behind when push came to
water's mighty shove here, those who were trapped have a simple
explanation: Their nickels and dimes and dollar bills simply didn't add
up to stage a quick evacuation mission.
"Me and my wife, we were living paycheck to paycheck, like most everybody else in New Orleans," Eric Dunbar, 54, said Saturday.
...
"He offered a mini-tutorial in the economic reality of his life.
"I
don't own a car. Me and my wife, we travel by bus, public
transportation. The most money I ever have on me is $400. And that goes
to pay the rent. And that $400 is between me and my wife." Her name is
Dorth Dunbar; she was trying to get some rest after days of peril.
Dunbar
estimated his annual income to be about $20,000, which comes from doing
graphic design work when he can get it. Before the storm, when he and
his wife estimated how much money they needed to flee the city, he was
saddened by the reality that he could not come up with anywhere near
the several thousand dollars he might need for a rental car and airfare."
If it wasn't harsh economic reality, it was about harsh family responsibilities:
"A 47-year-old grandmother was rocking a grandchild.
"These
people look at us and wonder why we stayed behind," said Carmita
Stephens. "Well, would they leave their grandparents and children
behind? Look around and say, 'See you later'?" She gave a roll of the
eyes behind the raised voice.
"We had one vehicle. A truck. I
wanted my family to be together. They all couldn't fit in the truck. We
had to decide on leaving family members -- or staying."
According to the article, she made it out with some family, but her husband and son are still missing.
Now I'm sure there one or two folks who didn't leave the city out of sheer pig-headedness, or a misplaced belief in their own immortality, or had been faked out by previous hurricanes and didn't want to be "tricked" again, or were just too optimistic, complacent, lazy, or smart for their own good.
But Mr. Brown, was last week a really good time to tell them what schmucks they were?
And President Bush, as a long-time supporter through thick and thin, and a card-carrying Republican, this constituent has but one question...what part of "Brownie, you're doing a heck of a job", did you truly mean this past Friday?